237 / 494
236
FINDINGS
9.64.
We find that Ms. Williams was a truthful witness and
we believe her account of the circumstances in which her sons Fabian
and Fernando Grant were killed. That evidence is suggestive of
deliberate murder by unidentified police officers. Ms. Muirhead’s
evidence corroborated Ms. Williams’ in respect of the manner in which
Fabian and Fernando were killed. We also accept Mr. Dacres’ testimony
that he saw their bodies in a truck driven by a police officer. Since the
evidence suggests, at a high level of probability, that these three men
may have been murdered, we recommend that there be further
investigation into their deaths.
9.65.
We believe Mr. Dacres’ evidence as well as Ms. Muirhead’s.
Their evidence speaks to the murder of “Porridge Man” and Orlando
Brown (Giffy) by police officers on the morning of 25 May 2010 at a
time when members of the JCF were retrieving dead bodies in Tivoli
Gardens. Ms. Muirhead also seems to have been an eyewitness to the
killings of Fabian and Fernando Grant. Since the evidence suggests, at
a high level of probability, that a criminal offence may have been
committed, we recommend that there be further investigation into the
deaths of Jermaine “Porridge Man” Grant and Orlando “Giffy” Brown.
(viii)
Kirk Allison and Dashard Page
Joan Haughton-Allison
9.66.
On 24 May between 12.30 p.m. and 1.00 p.m. Mrs. Haughton-
Allison was at home in Flat 22, Building #1, Levy Path with her husband,
Kirk Allison, son Dashard Page and others. She was about to start cooking when
she heard a loud explosion “like a bomb and the building shake”. Kirk was on
the verandah and he ran inside “crying for his ears”. Her six months’ old baby